Choosing the Right Birth Control: Weighing the Benefits and Risks

By RUBMD 7 Min Read

If you’re researching different birth control methods, kudos for taking an important step toward empowering your health and reproductive choices. Knowing how the different types of birth control options you have available lets you find one that suits your lifestyle.

Choosing a birth control method is a highly personal journey, and one size does not fit all. Each option has benefits, drawbacks, and potential side effects. Whether you’re seeking a temporary or permanent solution, we recommend considering your lifestyle, health conditions, and long-term family planning goals. 

Overview of Birth Control Options

Birth control methods fall into four primary categories: hormonal, barrier, permanent, and natural. Each approach offers distinct benefits and potential drawbacks, often tied to lifestyle, health, and convenience.

  • Hormonal: Among the most common forms of birth control for women, these varieties work by regulating hormones to prevent ovulation and create conditions in the body that are not conducive to conception.
  • Barrier: These birth control options prevent sperm from reaching the egg through physical barriers such as condoms or diaphragms.
  • Permanent: These surgical solutions prevent future pregnancies.
  • Natural: The original birth control, natural methods rely on understanding and tracking fertility signals to avoid conception.

Think about your priorities, too. While some people want high effectiveness, others might look for non-hormonal options or methods that don’t involve daily routines.

Hormonal Birth Control

Hormonal birth control methods include the birth control pill, patch, vaginal rings, injection, hormonal IUD, and progestin implants. These methods work primarily by releasing synthetic hormones (typically estrogen and/or progestin) to prevent ovulation, alter cervical mucus, or make the uterus less receptive to a fertilized egg.

  • Pros: Hormonal methods are known for their high effectiveness rates—when used as directed, they are over 90% effective at preventing pregnancy. Additionally, many people find that hormonal birth control offers extra benefits, like clearer skin, predictable periods, and reduced menstrual cramps. For some, certain types of hormonal birth control may also lower the risk of ovarian and endometrial cancers.
  • Cons: Hormonal birth control may cause side effects like weight changes, mood swings, headaches, and nausea. Some people may experience a decrease in libido or other long-term concerns with extended use. Injectable forms, like Depo-Provera, are sometimes linked to decreased bone density, a consideration for long-term users. 

Barrier and Non-hormonal Methods

Barrier methods include condoms, diaphragms, and cervical caps, while non-hormonal options also include the copper IUD, which prevents pregnancy by creating a sperm-toxic environment in the uterus. The IUD can be a good choice if you’re looking for hormone-free contraception.

  • Pros: Barrier and non-hormonal methods offer the advantage of being hormone-free, which can be ideal if you’re sensitive to hormones or want to avoid potential hormonal side effects. Additionally, barrier methods like condoms are available over the counter, making them an accessible choice. The copper IUD provides long-term contraception without the need for daily attention and can last up to 10 years.
  • Cons: A primary drawback is that barrier methods generally have lower effectiveness rates compared to hormonal methods and require correct usage each time to prevent pregnancy. Condoms can break, and other barriers must be precisely used to maximize effectiveness. The copper IUD can sometimes lead to heavier periods or cramping, especially in the initial months of use; potential side effects include weight gain and mood changes. 

Permanent Methods and Natural Options

Permanent birth control options include surgical procedures like tubal ligation for individuals with ovaries and vasectomy for individuals with testes. These methods are irreversible and designed for people who are confident in their decision not to have biological children in the future. 

Natural methods rely on fertility awareness-based methods (FABMs). These FABMs usually involve tracking the menstrual cycle to identify and avoid ovulation and other fertile times of the month.

  • Pros: Permanent methods offer the ultimate effectiveness and reliability, as they eliminate the possibility of future pregnancies without requiring further action or management. These methods provide solutions without hormone involvement. Similarly, natural options don’t rely on medications, thus avoiding any side effects.
  • Cons: The primary drawback of permanent methods is their irreversibility. If you want children in the future or are uncertain, explore other options. Natural methods, while hormone-free and non-surgical, require a high level of precision, commitment, and consistency to be effective. Because fertility signals can be influenced by factors like stress, illness, or irregular cycles, they may not be the most reliable option for everyone.

Additional Considerations and Consultations

Although over-the-counter options are accessible, it’s always wise to consult a healthcare provider to discuss medical conditions, lifestyle factors, and personal goals that could influence the decision. This is especially important when considering permanent or complex methods. Birth control options that may be safe and effective for one person may pose risks or limitations for another, especially for those with underlying health concerns.

If you have a partner, open communication about birth control preferences and responsibilities can encourage mutual understanding. That way, you’ll both feel confident and comfortable with the choice.

Making an Educated Reproductive Choice

We get it: You just read a lot of information that could initially seem overwhelming. We suggest speaking with a gynecologist or other healthcare provider for more clarity on how different methods align with your health and lifestyle needs. There’s no reason to feel shy about speaking up; your health and comfort are the top priorities, and their job is to guide you toward the right choice.

Share This Article
Leave a comment